Although I’m more inclined to show my school spirit by wearing pink and green more often than scarlet and gray, I was glad to be a Buckeye last night. I went to The Ohio State University’s Longaberger Alumni House to hear Pulitzer Prize-winning editorial cartoonist Nick Anderson talk about “Humor and Opinion: The Art of the Political Cartoon.”
Anderson joined Lucy Caswell, founding curator of Ohio State’s Billy Ireland Cartoon Library & Museum, and Herb Asher, professor emeritus of political science at Ohio State, for a conversation about how editorial cartoons influence the discussion about politics. Fred Andrle, former WOSU Open Line radio talk show host and current associate at Ohio State’s Humanities Institute, moderated the discussion.
Lucy began by describing how editorial cartoons are used in a democracy. Designed to inform, persuade and advocate, an editorial cartoon is the signed personal opinion of its creator. By combining words and pictures to comment on current events, editorial cartoons encourage readers to think about issues. Using visual and verbal cues from popular culture helps them convey messages that readers most likely will understand.
To illustrate how editorial cartoons provide commentary about leaders, Lucy showed Thomas Nast’s “Compromise with the South,” an editorial cartoon which ran as a two-page spread in Harper’s Weekly in September 1864. Its detail drew readers to return and look at it again, seeing new things they might have missed before. The powerful message of this cautionary tale about what would happen in the event of a Southern compromise led voters to re-elect Lincoln, she said.
Lucy also shared “No Honest Man Need Fear Cartoons,” Homer C. Davenport’s caricature of Senator Thomas Platt and Boss Tweed, as well as a detail from the November 11, 1919 edition of “The Passing Show,” the weekly full-page editorial cartoon that Billy Ireland created for The Columbus Dispatch in the early years of the 20th century. As we looked at Ireland’s depiction of the east bank of the Scioto River — today’s newly refurbished “Scioto Mile” — Lucy told us that Ireland was commenting on the fact that Columbus residents had voted on a referendum to clean up this view of the city the week before.
Then, Anderson described how he became interested in cartooning and how he relies on cartoons to get people thinking about current events.
Born in Toledo, Ohio as the youngest of 11 children, Anderson resolved to do something different from his siblings. As a boy, he bought a book on cartooning and became interested in the art form, following the work of Jeff MacNelly and Pat Oliphant. Later, Anderson studied political science at Ohio State and drew cartoons for The Lantern. He received The Charles M. Schulz Award for best college cartoonist in the United States.
The unusual graphic style and thoughtful, powerful messages that Anderson created in his editorial cartoons for the Louisville Courier-Journal won him a Pulitzer Prize in 2005. Among other awards, he won the Society of Professional Journalists’ Sigma Delta Chi Award in 2000. He submitted a question in animated form to the Republican CNN-YouTube presidential debates, which aired on November 28, 2007.
Today, Anderson, an avowed independent, draws cartoons for the Houston Chronicle. He is syndicated in over 100 newspapers by The Washington Post Writers Group. His work has appeared in The New York Times, Newsweek, The Washington Post, and USA Today.
Anderson’s cartoons are the result of a lot of hard work. To get his insights and opinions across in a way that differs from other editorial cartoonists, Anderson constantly follows the news and researches topics to form his ideas. While he has the confidence of his opinions, he doesn’t always have the confidence of his ideas, so he’s glad to share his rough drafts with his editors for their input, he said.
While Anderson can draw most of his cartoons in a couple of hours, depictions of more complicated topics can take him four or five hours to execute. Complex subjects lend themselves well to multi-panel cartoons.
During the course of Anderson’s career, the art of drawing a cartoon has changed. Before, cartoonists drew their work in pencil, traced it over with India ink, and then erased the original pencil lines. Now, many aren’t using paper at all, creating their work completely on the computer. Anderson uses Corel’s Painter software, which he uses in conjunction with the Wacom Cintiq computer touch monitor and a stylus.
While he loves creating original artwork, Anderson said he doesn’t have the leeway of time. Using the computer, he can undo his drawings, work in layers, and create cross-hatching much faster. Corel Painter allows him to color a cartoon in 20 to 30 minutes and gives a nice watercolor effect to his work. Whatever his technique, Anderson hides the names of his two children in each of his cartoons, providing a unique scavenger hunt for some of his followers.
Since cartoonists have to innovate more these days, Anderson has also tried his hand at clay animation. Herman Cain and Rick Perry have been the subjects of his experiments with Claymation. These expressions can take him about eight hours, between splicing the audio together and creating the clay models.
Social media is redistributing Anderson’s work in more interactive ways. Establishing a presence on Facebook and posting to a blog are also giving him more opportunities to receive instant feedback from his audience.
Anderson appeared on WOSU’s “All Sides with Ann Fisher” on Wednesday. Click here to hear what he had to say. To follow Anderson’s work, bookmark his blog.
While attending this alumni event provided me with the perfect opportunity to visit the Longaberger Alumni House, it also gave me a chance to see some unique Ohio State-themed ephemera and artwork. Buckeye license plates and an alumni edition of Brutus Buckeye are displayed near watercolors by local artist (and cartoonist) Leland McClelland and Ralph Fanning, an art history professor at Ohio State University who produced more than 3,000 watercolors and paintings. For more information about Fanning, read “A Painter and a Gentleman,” an article by George W. Paulson in the May-June 2000 issue of TIMELINE.
Filed under: Art, History, Ohio State University
